"You
want me to be something that I'm not!"
I sobbed.
" I'll never be the kind of daughter you want me to be!"
"Only
two kinds of daughters," she shouted in Chinese.
" Those who
are obedient and those who follow their own mind!
Only one
kind of daughter can live in this house. Obedient daughter!"
"Then I
wish I weren't your daughter, I wish you weren't my mother,"
I shouted. (Two
Kinds, 70)
This paper will explain a story of “ two
kinds “ present by Amy Tan, in short story the main character is Jing Mei and
Her mother.
Two kinds is a short story from book the Joy luck club by
Amy Tan that first published in 1989. The short story tell the main character Jing
Child's hood and the effect of his mother high hopes of her life. And some
event that occure in authors life that first character a mother leave china and
stay in america since 1949.
The reason why I choose the story for this final paper
because there are some problems experienced by every person, especially among children and mothers. And
in this story is very visible that is a tension between mother and daughter and
american dream. I want to know what tension that happen if a mother forced her
daughter to be full talented, and what happen if a daughter doesn’t wanted to
hear her mother to make her be someone that she is not.
Jing
mei is a chinese who live in america since her mother losing everything in
china at 1949. Her mother wanted that Jing Mei should be prodigy (full
talented). Jing mei's mother hope that her daughter will be great succes as
prodigy until her mother try to mold her daughter into a child actress, but
that doesn't work and finally her mother wanted jing mei to took a school
piano. Jing mei doesn't not play a piano but her mother forced her to study
hard until make Jing Mei feel not other way. Then Jing Jei follows what her mother
say and she learns how to play a piano. Jing me learns piano by Mr. Chong on
everyday, two hours a day from four until six.
A few
week later, Jing Mei follows in talent show, she was to play '
pleading child ' and when she turns came. She is very confident and she started
to play, at the beginning it was beautiful slowly and fast. Suddenly, there's
surprise when she hit the first wrong note, then she hits another and another
followed that. The audience just clapped weakly until her mother disappointed.
Jing mei is shocked and doesn't want to play piano again, she is not genius and
she regret it because her mother hope to make her as someone that she is not. Jing Mei
frustrating because it was not the only disappointment he feels, next year, she fails many times in every her wish, she
doesn’t become leader in class, she doesn’t get into college, dropped out in
college until she thinks that she can’t be anything that she want. After a lot of year, Jing Mei and her mother don’t
speak each other since thirty years
until her mother gives Jing Mei Piano for Surprise in birthday thirty.
Jing Mei says that Only two kinds of
daughters, they are loyal and they
are
following their own mind, it’s mean that the meaning of Two
kinds who present by Amy Tan is it. Amy Tan as a author try to show two
different sides between the child and the mother and two different wish, and we
should not do it, because it’s will be effect to our self each other and it
will make a conflict in a family.
Jing Mei
in this story is the character protagonist and her mother as antagonist character. in the story Jing Mei trying to
follow his mother's wishes to enter a beauty contest, then piano lessons to
strive to be the best, but Finally Jing Mei realizes that it is actually not
the intention and not her talent because she always failed in that regard.
her mother as antagonist character, he did not realize he was wicked and egoist
because sometimes impose his own will and make Jing Mei to do what she wants.
I try to understand
condition Jing Mei’s mother, in This story, her mother very Obsessed for
anything, when her mother took her in Shirley temple or beauty training school,
and when she is failed she try to took Jing Mei to School piano. It happen
because
Condition in america at
the moment was very stressed to be able to have a talent for many children who
have talented like auntie lindo daughter that is waferli, she is very smart in
playing chess and get many awards, until Jing Mei’s mother wanted same obsessed, beside that her mother very likes the
Ed Sullivan Show (a popular variety show that appeared on america television
since 1948). This condition then make her mother have obsessed althought her
daughter famus like in TV.
Jing
mei have poor physical condition because her mother wanted to be something that
she doesn’t like it. It was proven when Jing Mei say:
“ then I wish I’d never been born
!, I wish I were dead! Like them ‘. (Amy Tan, 74)
According
to experts psychology from england john bowlby (1989) say that the mother that
is not able to provide a sense of security to children in early development
will contribute to the negative things that finally will continue to be taken
to effect the future of children and stimulate of emergence of depression to
believe that the child commited left alone, could put and end to all of it and
resolve the issue. And what John Bowbly says that it’s really happen to Jing
Mei when her mother forced, when her mother took her to a school piano
althought she can not play piano, when her mother forced her to study hard,
when her mother always snap him.
So,
the conclusion about this story is the tension between them because her mother
always follow what she wishes and wanted
what other people can. And it’s not good, because what we wish not necessarily we can do it
and what other people can, not
necessarily we can do it. Everyone have a talented that different and we should
try to find it. And if we have not find it, trying is
the best way and never give up. Waiting is not good idea.
Cat : this is my first final paper, I don't know it's good, or Bad. but I feel proud because this is my own world...